|
Chapter Two:
Vaccines, Treatments and Condoms
What is a virus? -
Killing off the soldier
cells - Why you get ill - Newsflash
on Cures, Vaccines and Condoms - Rubbish
cures - What about a vaccine?
- Master of disguise - A
vaccine for flu - A
virus dressed up to look like you - Give
him a test - Condoms
are not the whole answer to AIDS - Condom
babies - Holey condoms! - You
can get infected even with a condom - Condoms
are like seat-belts - You
can't have an abortion for AIDS - Condoms
can be worn by women -
Condoms must be part of the Christian answer to AIDS - Dilemmas
for engaged couples - What about
smoking? - Condoms
are very costly for poor nations to give to everyone -
HIV is a development
issue - Experience in Africa
- Like any other sex disease
- Desperate for a test - One
partner for life - People
say Africa is different - How
can I keep uninfected ? - Zero risk
Extract from Aids and You - book by Dr Patrick Dixon,
published by Kingsway 1989, 1990, 2002
Introduction:Christians
are Leading the Fight Against AIDS - Chapter
1:AIDS is Your Problem Too - Chapter
2:Vaccines, Treatments and Condoms - Chapter
3:Agony AIDS - Questions People Ask Chapter
4:Nowhere to Go - Chapter
5:What Do You Think? - Chapter
6:Where Are You Going? - Finally:Time
for Action - ACET
International Alliance
Also read The
Truth about AIDS - free online book with much more AIDS information:
- Latest
AIDS statistics, AIDS information - Africa AIDS Crisis - History
of AIDS - AIDS epidemic, India, Asia, Eastern Europe, Central
Europe, Russia, America, China
- AIDS
research - causes of AIDS - AIDS treatment - retroviruses - protease
inhibitors - cure? Antiretroviral therapy for HIV
- HIV
transmission, AIDS risk factors and HIV window period
- What
is AIDS? - HIV symptoms - AIDS symtoms - symptoms early HIV infection
- early signs infection
- How
reliable are condoms? HIV dating - reducing HIV transmission
- Life
and death issues - HIV medicine
- AIDS
FAQ - vaccine, treatment, AIDS testing, Africa, China, Children,
workplace discrimination, AIDS myths, origin of AIDS
- Moral
dilemmas - euthanasia and AIDS treatments
- AIDS
and the church - when church members need help
- Community
care - treatment, adults, children, orphans
- AIDS
education - AIDS awareness in youth and schools
- HIV
Prevention - needle exchange program and condom distribution
- AIDS
in Africa and HIV in Africa, HIV infected surgeons
- Ten
point AIDS management plan for governments
- A global Christian challenge - church response to AIDS
- Guidelines
for best practice in running HIV / AIDS programmes in developing
countries, plus many helpful case studies and stories (Africa
/ India / Asia)
- A Christian
response to AIDS - global AIDS challenge to the church (article
for Tear Fund)
No one dies solely of AIDS
AIDS is a condition when a particular virus has weakened
your body so other germs can invade and kill you. That's what the
name 'AIDS' means: your body is usually very good at destroying
germs. We call this immunity. When your immune defences are badly
damaged, we say you are suffering from an immune deficiency. Some
people are born with bad immune systems and others acquire a deficiency
because of a disease. Because AIDS is acquired through an infection,
we call it the Acquired Immune Deficiency Syndrome (AIDS for short).
HIV just stands for Human Immune-deficiency Virus,
which is the scientific name for the virus which causes AIDS.
Whatever names we use, one thing is important and
that is to realise that there are stages from being infected, where
a person is an infectious carrier but well, through to early symptoms,
and then finally to more severe illness or death. The process takes
years.
It is totally impossible to tell by appearances who is infectious
and who is not.
What
is a virus? (Return to
Index)
A virus is just like a robot or a computer program.
It simply contains some written directions to teach cells in your
body how to make more viruses. A virus is made up of a bag of protein
with a small strip of genetic code inside it. This is like the code
that makes your hair brown, your nose short and your ears the shape
they are. Everything inside you is programmed by these genes, and
amazingly almost every cell in your body has inside it all the instructions
to make a complete carbon copy of you!
The code inside the virus only contains one or two
instructions, but wrong ones. If the virus sticks for more than
a moment onto the outside of a special type of white blood cell,
the virus bursts like a tiny bubble, squirting the lethal code into
the cell. Within a few minutes the cell has taken a copy inside
the cell brain (nucleus) and the cell brain has been permanently
reprogrammed. This cell is doomed.
Killing
off the soldier cells (Return
to Index)
For a few weeks or months, or even for a few years,
the infected soldier cell keeps floating around in the blood, or
swimming between the tissues of your body. The cell has one aim
in life: locate and destroy germs. There are hundreds of different
germs and each kind of white cell is designed to attack one kind
of germ.
Why
you get ill (Return to
Index)
Only certain kinds of soldier cells get attacked by
the virus, but as they get fewer and fewer it gets harder and harder
for your body to kill certain germs. You are fine with ordinary
coughs and colds. Most common germs are quickly destroyed, but one
or two just keep on growing. The result is a strange chest infection,
TB or other illnesses.
When a soldier cell meets the right shaped germ it
springs into action. After being sleepy for years it works overtime
to help produce antibodies. These fit exactly onto the outside of
the germ and destroy it. But if the cell has been reprogrammed,
the mechanism gets jammed. The new program jumps into action and
tells the cell to stop helping to make antibodies. Instead it starts
to make new viruses. The cell gets sicker as it gets larger. Eventually
it bursts, showering millions more virus particles into the blood.
Each one stays in the blood for only a few minutes before it touches
a fresh healthy white cell, bursts, injects the code and re-programmes
new cells-soldier cells and brain cells, for example.
After a while the body is weakened and other infections start
to take over.
Some of these infections simply cause you to feel
run down or to lose weight, but the chest infections can kill and
are very hard to treat. No one dies solely of AIDS. You die largely
because of the other infections that take over your body when your
defences are damaged, or from cancers related to HIV.
TB is a common killer of people with advanced HIV infection.
Newsflash
on Cures, Vaccines and Condoms (Return
to Index)
Almost every week it seems we read or hear about some
new wonder cure for AIDS. They say someone has already found a vaccine,
and they also tell us how sex is safe if you use a condom. These
things are good news if they are true - but are they?
Some say that if you have sex with a virgin you will be cured.
Nonsense. It is amazing what people will believe.
A lot of what you read and hear is rubbish. If it
was as easy as some people make out to find a cure, or if a good
vaccine really had been found, doctors, nurses, hospitals and governments
could stop worrying. The reason why there is so much fuss about
preventing the spread of infection is because the truth is that
there is no cure, nor is there one anywhere in sight. There is no
vaccine that works, nor is there likely to be one for at least ten
years. To make it worse, condoms are much less safe than some people
think they are.
I hope that soon we will have a drug that kills viruses
and is safe. When that happens, we will have a cure for flu, the
common cold, polio, hepatitis, herpes and many other illnesses such
as glandular fever; as well as a cure for AIDS. At the moment it
is a long way off.
At the moment we don't have the technology to do it.
Making a cure will involve us inventing some amazing tools that
will allow us to work inside individual cells in the body. Landing
a man on the moon or even on Mars is very simple compared to the
skills needed to find a cure. The person who finds a cure will go
down in history books as one of the greatest inventors of all time.
Books will be written about him or her well into the twenty-second
century.
In the meantime you will read of hundreds of false
'cures'. The trouble with AIDS is that people who have it don't
actually die of AIDS alone. As we have seen, they die of the infections
and problems that come in when AIDS has weakened the body. Anything
that helps the body get rid of these other infections can help someone
make a dramatic recovery. They go home looking well, and are sometimes
still completely well some months later. Until they get another
chest infection, people think they have been cured. This gives rise
to rumours and false reports:
'I took this special antibiotic and within a day I
was out of hospital and haven't looked back since. I don't have
AIDS any more.'
The first comment is right, the second is wrong. The
person could die quite quickly at any time. The soldier cells are
getting weaker and weaker, and with each passing day the body is
more and more wide open to new germs. Although the person may be
looking well he is sitting on a time-bomb.
Rubbish
cures (Return to Index)
In Uganda a few years back, drugs for tuberculosis
were being talked about as a cure for AIDS. Nonsense. People with
AIDS are especially likely to die of tuberculosis. The drug kills
tuberculosis, not AIDS. In the USA, treatments for syphilis have
been called treatments for AIDS. They are not - they help People
recover from syphilis alone.
Some people are pushing fad diets, whole-meal foods,
vitamins in large doses, exercise, sleep and psychotherapy in varying
combinations as a cure for AIDS. What value do these things have?
It is true that if your soldier cells aren't working
too well then anything that helps your immunity is going to help
keep you healthy, and things which make you run down and prone to
being ill should be avoided. Common sense tells you to take care
of yourself. Eat proper regular meals, take some exercise, keep
your weight reasonable, eat plenty of fresh fruit, cut out the smoking,
cut down on alcohol and stop all other recreational drugs, and make
sure you get enough sleep. These low-cost measures are likely to
prolong the life and well-being of most people and especially of
those with AIDS or early HIV infection.
However, some people are advertising all kinds of
very expensive and useless remedies. A lot of people are making
a lot of money out of AIDS.
It's true that there are some very expensive medicines
available in the West called HIV protease inhibitors and other things.
But these just damp down the fire, they don't put it out.
They are all poisonous so you can die from over-treatment
and that means many hospital tests.
The medicines have to be taken for life.
A Burundi doctor would have to save his entire salary
for five years to pay for treatment and monitoring of just one person
on these drugs for one year - and the person will still die of AIDS
in the end.
Because of this there has been a huge outcry for justice
and the manufacturers have taken steps to provide the drugs at much
lower cost.
But to people on $2 a day of income, they will still have
to save their entire earnings for two years to pay for two days
of treatment for a relative.
Just as the idea that everyone in the poorest nations
can afford to use condoms when they have sex, it is also stupid
to pretend that these lower cost drugs will make any difference
at all to the vast majority of the poorest people in the world.
Remember too, even if you can afford them, these treatments
are dangerous and useless without good laboratory facilities and
experienced medical teams.
The most appropriate use of such medicines is often to give
them to pregnant mothers who have tested positive, in a short course
of treatment, designed to reduce the risk to the unborn child of
becoming infected.
What
about a vaccine? (Return
to Index)
Vaccines are our only weapons against viral diseases.
Polio, whooping cough, measles and other illnesses are becoming
more rare now thanks to vaccines. A worldwide programme against
smallpox has now succeeded in wiping it off the face of the earth.
So why not AIDS?
A vaccine is made by giving you a germ that is harmless
but is the same shape on the outside as the disease germ. Within
a week you will develop special antibodies to get rid of it. The
first time it always takes longer. The next time you meet the same
germ, it takes only an hour or two to get your soldier cells into
battle. Your soldier cells can remember a germ they have met before
several years ago.
If you now meet a completely different and dangerous
germ, and the shape is the same as a germ your body has met previously,
your body is well prepared, and instead of dying of polio, for example,
you feel slightly unwell and get better in a day or two. The vaccine
has made you immune.
Master
of disguise (Return to
Index)
The trouble with AIDS is that the virus keeps changing
its shape so it confuses the soldier cells. A vaccine you give someone
today might protect him or her next week, but what about next month?
Here we have a virus that is immune to your soldier cells. That
is why your body can virtually never get rid of it. There are other
viruses that change shape as well. You may have wondered why flu
is still a major cause of lost days at work or at school, or why
all our skills are defeated by the common cold.
The reason is that both of these illnesses are caused
by viruses that tend to look a bit different every time you meet
them. By the time you have passed your cold on to a friend, and
it has been passed on another few dozen times, it has travelled
halfway round the world, infected maybe 10,000 people in total,
and has altered shape. Each person infected makes new viruses inside
their nose cells and sometimes the viruses coming out are not exactly
the same shape as the virus that came in.
A year or two later you meet someone with a cold -
the same cold you had before. If the virus were like measles or
chickenpox, your body would have remembered it and killed it straight
away. But the virus looks so different on the outside that when
the soldier cells get their picture library out, they just can't
identify it. There is no pre-made antibody that is a good enough
fit, so the soldier cells have to start all over again.
A
vaccine for flu (Return to Index)
There is a vaccine for flu and it just about works
because the virus tends to stay the same shape for a bit longer
than the cold virus. We have a look at what's coming round the corner
from the other side of the world. We take samples from people in
Hong Kong and Australia and we know that if we can get the vaccines
made and give it quickly to old people in the UK then we may be
able to reduce the number of flu deaths this winter. But you have
to have a new vaccine each year.
So even if we do find a vaccine for AIDS which is
safe and works, we will probably have to revaccinate everyone at
frequent intervals. The virus may still not be destroyed. It can
change shape in small ways even in the same person over a few weeks,
so antibodies that were a good fit at the beginning of the month
are almost useless by the end of the month.
A
virus dressed up to look like you (Return
to Index)
Whatever you may read, the truth is that we have never
yet found a single human antibody that is powerful against HIV -
even if it is exactly the right shape. Almost everyone who is infected
produces antibodies, but they still get ill and die. This virus
is immune to antibodies.
So when you next hear of some wonderful scientist
who has given himself a dose of AIDS vaccine, take care. The only
way we will know if it works is by giving him an injection of blood
from someone who has AIDS and seeing what happens. But how long
do you think you will have to wait to be absolutely sure, that he
will never develop AIDS? Possibly ten years Until then his wife
and children will he living in suspense, knowing that he might die,
and also that he may be an infectious carrier.
Give
him a test? (Return to
Index)
You may ask why we can't give him an AIDS test. Unfortunately,
the AIDS test is nothing of the sort. It is extremely difficult
to detect this tiny virus. The only widely available test we have
at the moment is not for the virus itself, but for the antibodies
that almost all infected people make. So people wanting a test often
have to wait a while after they were last at risk before being tested
- up to twelve weeks. If we find antibodies, it means that the person
has been exposed to the infection - or that he or she has developed
antibodies because of a vaccine. We cannot tell the difference.
Most experts are very depressed when it comes to talking
about vaccines. They say that we are almost certainly at least ten
years from a vaccine that works, and even if we find one it will
take years to make sure it is safe enough to give to large numbers
of people and to produce at low cost in large quantities.
Condoms
are not the whole answer to AIDS (Return
to Index)
Many churches don't like talking about condoms at
all.
But what is the truth?
Are condoms the medical answer?
Is promoting the use of condoms something that is opposed
to the values of Christ?
And another question.
If AIDS kills, the body can't fight it, drugs don't
really touch it and vaccines are as good as useless, then what hope
is there? Whenever I go into schools or talk to young people they
all tell me that safe sex is sex with a condom - even though they
may have also decided never to use one. But even if they were to
change their minds and to use condoms, do they really work as well
as people make out? Something no one likes to tell you is that condoms
may not be as safe as you' think they are.
Here is the truth:
Condoms can reduce the risk of HIV spreading enormously
but they are not 100% safe.
And here is a concern:
Sometimes indiscriminate promotion of condoms can
give a mixed message to young people: on the one hand encouraging
them to be celibate and then faithful, and on the other seeming
perhaps to encourage them to have multiple partners in situations
where they could be exposed to infection unless they use a condom.
Everyone agrees that one major thing more than any
other produced the sexual explosion of the swinging sixties, with
liberation of women from the fear of pregnancy, the ability to plan
a family reliably, and to explore free sexual relationships. The
swinging sixties were produced by the pill not the condom.
Condom
babies (Return to Index)
Before the sixties every mother warned her daughter
that if she slept around she could land up with a baby she didn't
want. Condoms have been around for years-since 1850 BC (not AD),
in fact. The ancient Chinese and the Romans knew all about condoms
and they were no more reliable then.
During the Second World War condoms were freely available
and were the main form of contraception, yet 'war babies', born
to women after hasty affairs with soldiers on leave, became a standing
joke. Thousands of parents and grandparents and aunts and uncles
today were born as 'war babies', or after the war, as 'condom babies'.
These were babies that surprised and shocked young girls who thought
they were safe from pregnancy because their boyfriends or husbands
were wearing condoms.
Even today the success of the latest condoms is not
as good as many people think when it comes to reliably preventing
pregnancy. If, as a doctor, I have 100 young women patients who
have chosen the condom to prevent themselves having babies, then
each year I can expect maybe fourteen of the 100 to come into the
surgery in a state of shock and confusion because they have missed
periods, but just can't believe they are pregnant because their
partners were using condoms.
Holey
condoms! (Return to Index)
Just for the record, condoms on sale, which are poor
quality can have up to seven out of ten with holes in them, faults
when you open the packet. The best have only one in 200 with a hole
in before you start. But what happens after you open the packet
is far more important. It can be quite difficult to use a condom
correctly. Fumbling in the dark it can be torn, caught in a woman's
jewellery, it can burst, fall off, roll off and leak if not removed
carefully at the end of making love.
If we are honest we have to say that no one is quite
sure why condoms have such an appalling habit of letting you down.
One good reason may be that people who say they are using them,
do buy them with good intentions, but when it actually comes to
the heat of the moment they don't get as far as putting them on.
You
can get infected even with a condom
(Return to Index)
If you were to draw a sperm and a virus on the same
scale, then if a sperm were ten centimetres long, a virus would
be the size of a pinhead. If sperm can cross from a man to a woman,
then viruses can too. They can also cross from a woman to a man.
It is not surprising then to find that reports are no now coming
in of men who have infected their wives, or the other way round,
with the HIV virus, despite using condoms carefully.
Even if a condom fails, a woman is unlikely to get
pregnant. You can only get pregnant on three out of thirty days
a month, and even if it happens to be a day when there is an egg
around to be fertilised, many people have to try many times before
a baby is conceived. In fact five in 100 people will never manage
it. Another five in 100 will take months or years of anxious trying
before they succeed in having a baby. Mr and Mrs Average take around
four months of trying.
But with HIV, you can in theory get infected any day
of the month. Once can be enough to get it from him or from her.
Condoms
are like seat-belts (Return
to Index)
Seat-belts save thousands of lives a year, but it
is feared that because people feel safer wearing them they actually
entourage speeding, jumping lights and crazy overtaking. In the
end people may land up in riskier situations, and the number of
lives saved may not be as great as it should have been.
Condoms are exactly the same: they reduce your chance
of dying from an activity which can be highly dangerous. By pushing
condoms and making out they are more reliable than they are, some
health campaigns may actually encourage people not to alter the
way they live. 'Carry on as normal, but just remember, when you
can, to use a condom.'
It is very simple: if you are going to take a risk
by having sex with someone who could be infected (and how will you
ever know, since people don't tell the truth and you can't tell
by looking) and you don't use a condom, you are crazy.
A condom may well save your life. Condoms have without
a doubt saved millions of people from dying of AIDS already.
When using condoms, make sure they are good quality.
Condoms can deteriorate in hot countries if kept for many months
before use. In conjunction, use a spermicide containing nonoxynol
to reduce risk further. If you want to use a lubricant, use those
which are water based and contain nonoxynol spermicide. Oil-based
lubricants can rot condoms in minutes.
But don't kid yourself that just because you use a
condom there will never be a baby or you will never become infected.
If you are having sex regularly with someone, or with
people who are carrying the virus, then one day, condom or no condom,
you may get infected. It is the same as someone who enjoys driving
a fast sports car beyond the limits of road - safety, thinking he
could never be killed in an accident because he always wears a seat-belt.
The seat-belt makes him safer -but it does not guarantee he won't
get hurt.
You
can't have an abortion for AIDS (Return
to Index)
Condoms reduce the risk by about 85-95%, but I wouldn't
trust my life to a condom. There are people who are infected or
have died, despite using them. Condoms are not as safe as some of
you think. All the health literature says that 'for safer sex use
a condom'. The trouble is that we hear what we want to hear. We
hear 'safe'. As someone said recently, you can abort a baby, but
you can't have an abortion for AIDS.
Condoms
can be worn by women (Return
to Index)
There are some new kinds of condoms available now.
They are made of the same material as ordinary condoms, but with
reinforcement to keep them in place inside a woman. They can provide
an added measure of protection. The trouble is that when a man and
woman are actually making love, these very thin membranes of rubber;
whether worn by a man or a woman, can slip or move. Things happen,
and neither partner is aware until afterwards when it is too late.
The stronger and thicker you make these things, the less and less
people want to have anything to do with them. The ideal condom is
invisible, with neither partner aware at all of anything feeling
any different. It doesn't exist, although some say the female condom
is an improvement, and it can be re-used many times.
35 million have been sold world-wide.
Condoms
must be part of the Christian answer to AIDS
(Return to Index)
Churches take very different positions on the condom
issue but however anti-condom a church may be, consider this:
a man comes to the pastor because he has been infected through
a blood transfusion and is worried about the health of his wife.
Both have been tested.
He is infected but she is not.
What advice will he be given?
Surely the only advice that makes sense is for both husband
and wife to understand that there is a serious risk to her life
if they have unprotected sex, but that if they use a condom carefully,
every time they make love, it will reduce the risk of her getting
infected enormously.
In such a situation it would be madness, almost perhaps an
act of murder, not to inform the couple of the real benefits of
condom use.
In such a situation let us work out the risks.
We know that if both partners are healthy, apart from one
having HIV, that is to say if neither have untreated syphilis, gonorrhea,
chancroid or another chronic sexually transmitted disease, then
in normal heterosexual intercourse, the chances of transmitting
HIV during a single episode is probably less than one in 200.
And we know that using a condom may reduce this risk further
by 90% or more.
That means that the risk of getting HIV from your husband
or wife if you are using condoms carefully in such a situation is
probably less than one in 2000.
In other words, on average such a couple would need to make
love 2000 times before the uninfected partner gets HIV.
Of course it could happen after just twenty times, or not
even after 10,000 times.
It's an average figure that you would get by following up
what happens to hundreds of couples.
So for a Christian it seems obvious that in some circumstances
at least there should be no reservations whatsoever about the use
of a condom where the aim is to save the life of a husband or wife
in marriage .
How much further we go down this route depends on the church
and as I say traditions and cultures vary hugely.
Dilemmas
for engaged couples (Return
to Index)
Incidentally, some church leaders in badly affected
countries are saying that they will not marry couples unless they
have been tested, and if one or both have HIV they forbid them to
marry. But I cannot find a bible passage that supports such action.
Clearly we should encourage people to be very caring and
responsible.
If both man and woman have HIV I cannot see any reason medically
why they should not marry, any more than two people with cancer.
Most likely they will think very carefully before attempting
to have children, partly because of the risk of infecting them,
even though HIV drugs can reduce that risk if taken in pregnancy.
But partly also because of the risk to the welfare of the
child if orphaned at a young age.
An engaged couple where one is infected and the other
is not are in a terrible situation, because they are entering a
life-long relationship where the act of greatest intimacy could
kill one of them.
But even so it seems to me that these things are matters
of sensitive personal counsel and cannot be made absolute rules
of the church.
What
about smoking? (Return
to Index)
I was recently debating this whole issue of condoms
with many church leaders in Burundi.
I asked them if they approved of smoking.
They said no.
I pointed out that you can smoke cigarettes with filters
or without but filtered cigarettes are far safer, they kill less
people.
So if they had a friend who insisted on smoking, would they
encourage them to smoke filtered cigarettes?
Would they explain how much safer it was?
Or would they feel it was just encouraging people to smoke
even more?
They agreed that however much they were against smoking,
the last thing they would want is for cigarettes to be even more
dangerous and they would agree that government advertising should
explain that smokers are better off using filtered brands.
I pointed out it was in many ways the same kind of
argument with condoms.
If someone is going to take a risk anyway (despite all our
persuasions), and could lose their life as a result of having sex
with an infected partner tonight, don't we have the same obligation
to warn them of the risks, and explain how to avoid a slow death
sentence?
So for me the issue is clear:
we do all we can to encourage celibacy and faithfulness,
but we also make people aware that there is a way of reducing the
risk of death, if they choose to go their own way.
Condoms
are very costly for poor nations to give to everyone
(Return to Index)
There is another problems with condoms: cost.
Only the female condom can be used more than once safely.
So who is going to supply them?
ACET International Alliance - the network of AIDS
programmes in many nations that I helped found in 1988 - was once
offered 140 million Chinese condoms delivered to any port in Africa
for a certain price.
I told them that even if we had the money, I calculated that
140 million condoms would last the continent of Africa just one
night - and then what would people do?
And what is more it would wipe out our entire budget for
HIV for a very long time.
Even the World Health Organisation does not have enough money
to fund such schemes on a sustainable basis. The Health Ministry
in Uganda was offered half a million condoms by a wealthy business
man in 1990 and had the same reaction:
"thanks very much but it will last our country a day".
We have to think more deeply than pieces of rubber.
We have to face reality.
We have to think on a far larger and longer scale.
Condoms may be a solution for wealthy people, able
to buy as many as they need, or for those fortunate enough to live
near a free distribution point but one thing is clear:
wealthy nations are unwilling and unable to pay out enough
money for every sexual act to be rubberised in the 2/3rds world,
so the idea that we should just tell everyone to use condoms is
a cruel joke.
And when 2 billion people exist on incomes of less than $2
a day, living in countries where the health budget is only $2 a
person for a whole year, how can condoms be a sustainable and affordable,
locally appropriate solution.
Condoms have to be produced in high-tech factories,
to high standards, packaged carefully, and stored well.
That's why they are expensive and an odd "Western-style"
solution for a low-tech society where many villagers may have very
few manufactured items: a plastic water container, a couple of metal
cooking pans, a battery radio and the clothes they wear.
Everything else is produced locally from what grows or is
dug from the earth.
Are we really expecting condoms to be the answer in places
like this?
Of course, condoms also have an advantage of providing birth
control for those that want it, but the practical issues remain.
HIV
is a development issue (Return
to Index)
That's one of the reasons we conclude that HIV is
a development issue.
For many reasons, poverty encourages spread.
Ignorance, lack of health care, poor communications, destitution,
children earning money or food from casual sex, and so on.
These cycles of deprivation need to be broken together.
Just focussing on HIV will not itself succeed in halting
AIDS.
Take for example an infected commercial sex worker:
how is she to live if she stops providing her services to
men?
Who will feed her children?
Who will pay for her medicines?
Prevention campaigns are not enough.
We need a holistic approach.
That's why one of the weapons against HIV is economic
growth: encouraging investment, business and international trade.
Microbanking, income-generation schemes, and other self-help
programmes have a vital role to play, not only in raising general
incomes in a nation, but also in helping those with HIV rebuild
their lives and helping orphans survive.
I have seen 40,000 people lifted simultaneously out of absolute
poverty in places like Delhi:
people who had been in tents and slum dwellings now living
in two story houses with all facilities, and with successful businesses,
largely as a result of micro-banking schemes, where groups of women
take out small loans together for several businesses and guarantee
each other.
As we have seen, AIDS is a terrible disease for which
there is no cure and no vaccine. The only hope is to teach people
how to protect themselves from infection.
If there is no cure, no vaccine, and condoms merely reduce
the risk as well as being unaffordable or unavailable for hundreds
of millions of people, what is the answer?
Experience
in Africa (Return to Index)
Just a few weeks ago I flew to a country where an
answer has been urgently needed to prevent a big part of
a whole generation from being wiped out. Uganda has had in
the past more reported cases of AIDS than any other country in Africa.
You might think that means it is the worst affected: it is not.
It is certainly the country with the most honest and courageous
leaders.
And has had one of the most successful campaigns in the world
with dramatic results.
There were several other African nations that had
as bad a problem, or maybe even worse, who would not speak up. One
country actually reduced the number of AIDS cases it admitted to,
even though doctors in that country knew the figures were fixed.
If people think you have a lot of AIDS then big companies pull out
and tourists stop coming. The economy collapses and in addition
to having thousands of extra sick young people to look after, you
now have high unemployment and increasing poverty.
The government of Uganda openly admitted there was
a big problem. This opened the doors for international aid and also
for education. How can you educate people about a major cause of
death when you don't officially admit anyone is actually dying of
it?
In some parts of central Africa, one in three
of all the truck drivers who drive lorries up and down the main
highways are infected, and half the young girls who hang around
the bars at night. Maybe one in five of all young men and women
in some of these towns are infected. Some have said they think there
are towns in central Africa where maybe half of all the sexually
active young people are dying.
Like
any other sex disease (Return
to Index)
I met a mother who had lost two daughters. Her face
was a picture of grief. Composed and dignified, she told me how
they had died. 'I wish it had been me,' she said, 'they were so
young.' In Africa the infection has always spread like any other
sex disease: from man to woman and woman to man. Europeans who stay
in these countries often come home infected after having had sex
only a few times.
In 1988 I visited Uganda for the first time: we spoke
to over 20,000 people in around ten days, at the request and invitation
of the Ministries of Health and Education. When we went into schools
and asked for a show of hands from those who knew personally of
people who had died because of AIDS, half would put up their hands.
Two years later it was almost everyone.
We held large open-air meetings with a big noisy African
band, a huge public address system and interpreters. Thousands attended
from local villages. Up to 2,500 people sat in the square or stood
motionless, six deep for around three hours, while we assisted the
local people in educating and answering questions. Most of the audience
were men - hardly ever turning up to such things normally. They
came because in the area where we were, AIDS had become a life and
death issue for everyone there.
Desperate
for a test (Return to
Index)
Many young people came to me wanting to be tested.
They had good reason to be worried. They knew there was a very high
chance that either of two people about to get married could be infected.
If they both are, that is one thing, but if not, then one could
kill the other. What should they do? It is quite feeble just to
tell them to use condoms carefully for the rest of their lives.
What about children? If the girl has a baby, she knows
that the infection can be passed in the milk. She wants to be tested
to make sure she does not accidentally kill her baby. A wife came
to me. She was worried because her husband was often out with other
women late at night. He admitted he had been repeatedly unfaithful
over the last ten years, and they both realised that he could easily
be infected, like so many of the people he knew who had died. They
wanted to know if it was safe for him to sleep with anyone again
- let alone his wife.
All these anxious people: they do not only need counselling.
Some of them have an urgent need for a test. Testing is one of the
most powerful weapons we have in the fight against AIDS because
it helps identify people who are carrying the virus so they can
take steps not to kill those they love or have casual relationships
with.
It also helps other people discover that they and their partners
are not infected, so they can enjoy anxiety-free, rubber-free sex
for life with no risk whatever of HIV unless one or other is unfaithful.
One
partner for life (Return to Index)
The response of the Ugandan government to the crisis
was prompt and impressive. No watered down messages. For them the
answer was obvious and clear: 'Safe sex is sex between virgins now
married for life. ( If you really can't manage it a condom might
save your life.)'
In Africa many governments have been very worried
too about spread from medical treatments. In some areas one in five
pints of blood donated to the hospital blood banks is full of virus.
Fortunately almost everywhere now in Africa they have facilities
to test all blood. Needles can also be in short supply, or equipment
to heat and sterilise can be broken or unavailable. No one will
ever know just how many people doctors and nurses have killed in
Africa without knowing it. So an important part of the health campaign
has been making sure that everyone is aware of the dangers of blood
and needles.
People
say Africa is different (Return
to Index)
A lot of people have tried to think up various reasons
why Africa is different. You must make up your own mind. Some said
that Africans are especially sensitive to HIV and that is why it
spread so fast. They worked out that answer from experience in a
London clinic. For six months that was the answer trotted out around
the world, until the doctors made a public confession that they
had wrongly added up the figures.
The next answer given was that Africans are much more
promiscuous. People believe what they like to believe. While it
is certainly true that some patterns of behaviour encourage multiple
sexual partners in parts of Africa, the difference is not enough
to explain what is happening.
Another suggestion was that medical treatments with
dirty, needles and infected blood was the reason. It is easy to
make armchair assessments when you are 6,000 miles away. The fact
is that if that were true then every age group that receives medical
care by injection would be likely to get AIDS, whereas most of those
infected are young sexually-active men and women.
Finally, some suggested that infection first with
one disease could open the body to infection by another. We have
very strong reasons to think this happens. Common sense tells us
that if you are already chronically sick and then you are infected
by the AIDS virus, you are not in the best possible shape to fight
it. Malaria and other tropical diseases could be responsible.
However, the most likely explanation is other sex
diseases. These spread in all countries but chronic untreated STDs
are far more common in poorer nations where there are fewer health
care facilities.
In addition, tracing sexual partners of those infected can
be harder in nations with less well-organised community systems.
We do know that if a man or a woman is infected with gonorrhoea
or syphilis or similar diseases, the small wounds made by these
germs become easy ways into the body for the AIDS virus.
One of the reasons that HIV is spreading so fast in
places like Mumbai in India is that around half of all adults in
that vast city are carrying an active untreated STD.
You can see for yourself that everything that has
happened in central Africa is bound to happen to some extent in
the West. It is a stupid man who comes back from a detailed look
at what is happening in Africa and says AIDS will never spread affect
people other than gay men and drug addicts in the UK.
Not only stupid but ignorant too:
in 2001 the majority of people newly infected in the UK were
heterosexuals - and mostly infected in other nations.
How
can I keep uninfected ? (Return
to Index)
You need to make a decision if you have not already
done so, that the next person you have sex with will be the person
you are committed to making love to for the rest of your life. Some
say life is not that simple. What if that person has had several
partners before, or what if you have? What if your partner is unfaithful
or is injecting drugs?
The question of testing is a difficult and complex
one and every person or couple is different. Where the risk is significant
it may well be worth one or both being tested for the sake of the
other. You need expert medical advice from your doctor or from a
special clinic.
The other decision-you need to make, if you have not
already done so, is never, never under any circumstances to allow
yourself to he injected with a needle that could contain traces
of someone else's blood.
Zero risk
(Return to Index)
If you keep to these two very simple things you will
reduce your risk to nearly zero. Any remaining risk would be if
your partner was continuing to take risks - especially if you are
kept in the dark - or if you are in the medical or caring professions.
If you fall into this group you should already have clear instructions
on how to protect yourself while also giving excellent care. The
basic rule is to keep blood and any other body fluids off your skin
as far as possible.
In the next chapter we look at some of the common
worries and problems people have.
What is a virus? -
Killing off the soldier
cells - Why you get ill - Newsflash
on Cures, Vaccines and Condoms - Rubbish
cures - What about a vaccine?
- Master of disguise - A
vaccine for flu - A
virus dressed up to look like you - Give
him a test - Condoms
are not the whole answer to AIDS - Condom
babies - Holey condoms! - You
can get infected even with a condom - Condoms
are like seat-belts - You
can't have an abortion for AIDS - Condoms
can be worn by women -
Condoms must be part of the Christian answer to AIDS - Dilemmas
for engaged couples - What about
smoking? - Condoms
are very costly for poor nations to give to everyone -
HIV is a development
issue - Experience in Africa
- Like any other sex disease
- Desperate for a test - One
partner for life - People
say Africa is different - How
can I keep uninfected ? - Zero risk
Introduction:Christians
are Leading the Fight Against AIDS - Chapter
1:AIDS is Your Problem Too - Chapter
2:Vaccines, Treatments and Condoms - Chapter
3:Agony AIDS - Questions People Ask Chapter
4:Nowhere to Go - Chapter
5:What Do You Think? - Chapter 6:Where
Are You Going? - Finally:Time for
Action - ACET
International Alliance
Press
/ TV | Lectures |
Dr Patrick Dixon
| Future of Banking |Digital Consumers
Genetics and Cloning |
Life & Health
| Global Change | Search
our site |